As the COVID-19 pandemic continues to ravage the globe, with confirmed cases and deaths increasing daily, and mutations emerging in some countries, the importance of personal and environmental hygiene has never been more critical. Amidst the heightened awareness, a variety of multi-purpose disinfectant sprays have appeared in the market, promising broad-spectrum disinfection without the need for dilution or rinsing. These products are touted for their ability to sanitize surfaces, objects, hands, and even the air. However, the question remains: Are these sprays truly effective?
The Consumer Council of Hong Kong recently conducted a comprehensive study on 15 multi-purpose disinfectant spray samples, ranging in price from HK$88 to HK$798 per bottle or set. The aim was to evaluate the efficacy of these products in killing germs and viruses, as well as to analyze the concentration of active chlorine components and their pH levels, and the stability of these components in the formulations.
Test Samples and Results
The 15 samples included in the study were purchased from department stores, home goods specialty shops, personal care stores, baby用品 shops, and online retailers. The active ingredients varied, with 9 samples containing hypochlorous acid (HOCl), commonly referred to as hypochlorous water, with concentrations ranging from 50ppm to 210ppm. Three samples claimed to contain chlorine dioxide (ClO2) or oxychlorine compounds, while the remaining 3 were made from plant extracts without specifying the chemical names.
The study found that all but one sample (#12) were labeled for use on objects, environments, or air, and could also be used for hand sanitization. Additionally, 12 of the samples claimed to have virus-killing capabilities.
Factors Affecting Efficacy
The efficacy of disinfectant sprays can be influenced by several factors:
-
Concentration of Active Ingredients: Higher concentrations of active ingredients generally lead to better disinfection results. However, there is a limit to how high the concentration can be before it becomes unsafe for humans.
-
Contact Time: The duration the disinfectant is in contact with the surface or object being sanitized is crucial. Some products may require a longer contact time to achieve effective disinfection.
-
Surface Type: Different surfaces may require different types of disinfectants. For example, porous surfaces may require a different approach compared to non-porous surfaces.
-
Environmental Conditions: Temperature, humidity, and other environmental factors can impact the effectiveness of disinfectants.
-
Proper Use: The method and frequency of application are also essential. Users must follow the instructions provided by the manufacturer to ensure the product works as intended.
Recommendations and Proper Use
The Consumer Council emphasized the importance of using disinfectant sprays correctly. Users should:
- Read and follow the instructions provided by the manufacturer.
- Apply the product evenly and ensure adequate contact time.
- Use protective gloves if necessary to prevent skin irritation.
- Avoid inhaling the spray directly to prevent respiratory irritation.
Conclusion
The study provided valuable insights into the effectiveness of multi-purpose disinfectant sprays. While some products demonstrated good efficacy in killing germs and viruses, the results varied significantly among the samples. Consumers are advised to research and choose products carefully, considering the active ingredients, concentration, and proper usage instructions.
As the pandemic continues, the importance of maintaining high standards of hygiene cannot be overstated. The right disinfectant, used correctly, can play a crucial role in protecting personal and public health.
Views: 0